It's the classic restaurant of Toronto. How does it do it? Consistently great service, food and a wine list that is so big, you're better off asking the sommelier for help (even if you know your stuff).
Treat this as your fun uncle's place that you haven't been to in ages, and they'll treat you like the awesome relative that they haven't seen in ages and will make you feel at home.
Yes, you pay a premium, but if you're planning a fun night out with friends you can't do wrong with this place.