I was really excited to try this on a trip back to Cleveland for the holidays. I had seen so many posts about the original location on instagram and was determined to get it now that it is slightly closer to where my family lives.
I got takeout and decided to go for the signature OMG Philly with plain fries. I did go without the mushrooms but idk if that would have really added anything to the experience. The sandwich itself was large and and the shrimp on top made it look so appetizing. I was expecting to bite into a flavor bomb of a meal but honestly, it was lacking any seasoning at all, like not even salt. My mom ordered the same sandwich and had similar feelings so I don't think it was a one-off experience. Also the actual filling of the sandwhich was way overpowered by the sauce they used, and we could barely taste the chicken or other vegetables. This meal cost us about $30 and we felt like it definitely was overpriced and not worth it.
On a positive note, the feeling of the restaurant itself was very relaxed and everyone I interacted with including the cashier and the girl who took my order were pleasant.
This place is definitely overhyped and nice if you want to post an indulgent looking meal on instagram but if you're actually hungry, go somewhere else. Bottom line: it's edible but not the best.