I'm surprised I haven't left a review of this place yet because it is definitely one of my favourite places to go in the city!
The variety of arepas you can order is amazing. I try to make sure to order a different one every time I come (but the carne asada is always a good choice). Everything is made fresh and comes to you piping hot. I usually also order the tostones (deep fried plantains) as either a side or an appetizer. The three sauces they give you are great to use especially the garlic mayo. Warning: when they tell you that the hot sauce is hot... it is!
Note: Bathrooms are not accessible because they are downstairs.