I got a chance to drop by Barton Snacks, and am happy to say that this place is a solid 3 stars.
The storefront is a cozy 5*10ft rectangle with a selection of ... I want to say...6 flavours of ice cream and a handful of "alternative" snacks. You won't see any national brands here; the merchandise features Johnny Ryan soda, Chocosol chocolate, and brands of chips that I can't even remember.
Boyfriend and I walked away with two small ice creams, 2 scoops each, with a $7 dent in my wallet. While it was delicious, we lamented that we could have bought an entire tub of Haagen Dazs or Ben & Jerry's with that money.
Bottom line: cute and sweet and way beyond my budget.