It sucks to see all the negative reviews for this place. I've always had a great experience.
I'm not ashamed that I have been known to go here several times a week for dinner. The weekday special are just unbeatable. $2 dogs on Monday, $1 breakfast items on Wednesday, $3 burgers on Thursday, and 42% off your food bill on Friday, every week 3 p.m. - close. I can't even make dinner for that price.
I hardly ever come here on the weekends due to the fact that it's very busy and without the deals the menu is a little expensive for me. But they do serve food made with local and organic ingredients which will obviously cost a little more. So I get why the prices are a little higher. Every once in awhile I treat myself on a Saturday morning to one of their vanilla chai lattes, another favorite.
My advice: Try going on a weekday for dinner. Take advantage of the deals. Try the ice cream. Your faith in Wild Goats might be restored.