3.5 stars
We all shared oysters-- chefs pick. We were served 4 oysters each and there was a wide variety. They were really good, although slightly pricey.
I had the popeye salad and the red chowder (highly recommended by the waiter over other chowders). The salad was delicious, and I'd definitely order it again. Very peppery and fresh. Unfortunately the red chowder tasted like a basic vegetable soup. I LOVE clam chowder and was excited to try this place. I would not recommend the red chowder and I don't know why two waiters both recommended it.
My friends had the chowder of the new and the crab grilled cheese and liked them but weren't raving about them.
We sat outside which was really nice on a beautiful spring day! Service was good as well.