I have visited this place a couple of times to pre-game for a D-backs or Suns game. I now spend my money at Rose and Crown which I think has way better food and drink options.
Meal: I usually would go with a burger or the nachos. The beer selection is decent.
Taste: The food is incredibly bland and I have serious doubts that they actually cook anything. I think everything they get is pre-packaged and they just warm it up. The beer is also not very good. They have a good selection but I don't think they clean their tap lines out very often. Every time I have drank a draft beer from there, the beer smells a little musty and tastes like mildew. 6 out of 10.
Value: Portions are decent, the food should taste way better for what you are paying for, and the beer prices are crazy high. Its not bad if you hit happy hour or some other special, but frankly, there is no real value at Cooperstown. 2 out of 5.
Service/Cleanliness: Ehhhhh . . . that is the only way I can describe it. The level effort put forth by the servers is the bare minimum. 6 out of 10.
Atmosphere: It seems like the managers/owners are trying to0 hard. The servers are all gothed out and it comes off as hokey. The sports and music stuff on the walls is pretty cool and the outdoor patio is awesome. 3 out of 5.
Overall: Forget Cooperstown. Do yourself a favor and go to Rose and Crown down the street instead. 17 out of 30 points, 1 out of 5 stars.