I had a previous wonderful experience here, but after trying something different on the menu last night, I'm not so sure that EVERYTHING on the menu is a hit.
We started with the spinach and feta dip. It was good (how can it not be?) but a bit greasy. I then went with the chicken gyro. It wasn't well-balanced. The sauce was all over the lettuce, but not the chicken itself, making it really dry. On top of that, it just wasn't good-quality chicken. I figured they'd use the rotisserie chicken in it, but it tasted really cheap. I didn't end up finishing it because it really wasn't that great. My wife also had something different from last time (the lamb gyro), and didn't love hers either.
I think we're a bit more cautious now. Maybe it just depends on what you order.