This place is awesome, I would absolutely return.
The environment overall was OK. Nothing stood out but it was good enough to have a good eating experience.
The pepperoni roll/muffin/whatever appetizer was delicious. It was not quite as good as the similar offering from Old Chicago, but it was still great. They had great deals on beer, which they served in a mini-pitcher. Wasn't even happy hour and I felt like the price was great.
The table all enjoyed their food. I ended up ordering a pasta dish that was absolutely delicious. I would return again for that alone.