We only went here because we had friends in town who wanted to. Let me sum it up fast -
Service was slow but very nice. Our server was super sweet....but painfully slow.
Prices were high - $23 for Shephard's pie. Now it was ok but a very small serving. I prefer Ri Ra to this one.
Decor was eh. We had dinner reservations for 7 people. We got seated at a high top with backless seats. Normally I prefer bar seating but when you have dinner reservations I prefer a table. Or at very least a seat with a back. To me it shouted "eat your food and get out".
Food is ok. Definitely not worth the price. We had a filet, Shephard's Pie, Steak and Ale pie, corned beef, truffle fries (Gordon Ramsay - didn't you say something about truffle oil being one of the most pungent, ridiculous ingredients ever known to chef?), and wings. Everything was edible but would not draw me back.
For this one, yelp is spot on - 3 stars. Don't waste your time and money here unless it's the only place that can seat you.