The New Yorker pizza definitely lived up to the hype, but the service was AWFUL. I never received a refill on my drink AND the server (Ryan) never checked on us after taking the order. We sat for about 40 minutes waiting for a refill, box and the check and finally had to ask someone to help us.
I would go back for the food, but am not sure due to the service and the lack of caring.
Too bad that such a great place has employees that don't care about customer service.