I love Red! I live in the neighborhood and eat here quite frequently. the staff always makes good suggestions and I've always liked everything I've gotten!
The reason for the 4 instead of 5 stars is the following. I went there this past Thursday for my birthday with my sister and two friends. We got some apps, drinks and sushi. My sister insisted on telling the waitress it was my birthday and after the plates were clear she said to me specifically 'what would you like for dessert...' and then gave me the options. My friend then asked if he could order dessert as well. I was surprised when the bill came and I was charged for my dessert. Now it's not the money just the way she offered it to me that I found strange.
Regardless, I will continue to dine at Red and look forward to several other meals