We had Athenas for the first time last night. I'm giving 4 stars because, while everything was delicious and the service was great, our pizza was really undercooked.
We had asked for extra cheese on our pizza, which upon opening the box, looked AMAZING. Then I took a bite and the dough seemed soggy and undercooked.
The mild wings and mozzarella sticks were delicious though.
Great customer service as well.