I've been here a couple of times, and I've always enjoyed it. Great selection of tasty beers, and the bands are usually pretty good. I like the whole bar-in-a-house vibe, and unlike The Roosevelt, you can usually find somewhere to sit or stand without feeling awkwardly in the way.
Sometimes the music is a bit too loud to carry conversation (although I guess this could be a good thing depending on who you go with). I've also been told by my wine drinking friends that the wines aren't great here, but if you are going to a bar to drink wine, I think you have bigger problems.