I'm sorry, but I really don't get what some of the negative reviews are all about. We had an AWESOME time at this bar! The pianists were all super talented...often rude but in a hilariously funny way, so if you can't take a joke or two then you would probably not enjoy it. Having grown up on the east coast myself, I thought that the bar fully embodied what an old school bar in New York would be all about.
Oh and don't go if you are cheap. Those guys try to get a bidding war going for songs...but its fun and enjoyable and they get the crowd going. I thought for the amount of singing & entertainment they provided, they deserved every penny of my tip. I mean, when you are in Vegas, you can't expect to not spend money. This place provided a fun night without dropping your entire paycheck on one bill.
We went Saturday and Sunday night. I have to agree with the fact that its more fun with more people at this bar...usually around 10PM on a weekend there's a decent crowd. I don't know about the other nights since I've only gone twice. Most fun I've had in Vegas in some time!