Pizzeria Libretto is the standard bearer for the "popular local pizza" category. They have the classic ovens, source tomatoes from Italy, and do lots of little things to keep their pizza true to its Neapolitan roots. This can get frustrating when you want a non-traditional topping such as pineapple (don't ask), yet the white and red sauce-based pizzas are delicious.
In addition to pizza, they offer great salads, sides, and have a full bar.
If you are choosing between their three or four locations, this one is newer and less known. That being said, it is much easier to get a table here.
Service at this location is exceptional. They go above and beyond to provide a great customer experience in a town where this does not typically happen.