Been to this place twice, first time in the summer of 2004 with some out of town friends. It was all around good. We all enjoyed our meals. And here is the reason for the low rating. My boyfriend and I went back, with the same out of town friend, Nov 2008 and the quality of the food had dropped to below standards. The service was fair and that is being kind. the appetizer was cold and flavorless. The pizza we had was barely cooked and I'm still suffering for it 3 hours later. If you enjoy sucking down a vast amount of pepto-bismol you will love this establishment. If not skip this place at all cost. I would head to Pizza Hut before going back to Papa Nick's.