First time in Sun Prairie. In town for the weekend from Green Bay for some AAU basketball. Found this place on Yelp. When I travel I like to dine at places I can't in Green Bay. I would tell you this is a must have if you are ever in the area. Their pie reminded me of Lombardi's in Manhattan which is one of my favorite joints. Took my 14 yo old son and one of his team mates. We had the 18" Fat Uncle Tony pie with the antipasti as an appetizer. Boys weren't crazy about the antipasti. Shocker, right?! However, the pie didn't stand a chance. I enjoyed the antipasti and would recommend it for the adults out there. We also had the cannoli for desert. Very delish as well. I thought the prices were very reasonable considering the quality of food, atmosphere, and service. I've certainly spent more on less worthy. Bit of a lengthy wait on a Saturday night at around 7:00. About 65 minutes. I would recommend calling ahead or a reservation if possible.