I've been looking to try this place ever since Ray's pizza closed and another place very close by which has been my substitute was closed.
First, this is not hand tossed pizza - it is pretty much the same pizza you get at Domino's, Little Caesars and the like. It's pressed dough, not foldable, and just doesn't distinguish itself from any other local pizza place. I was very disappointed as I drove past three other places to try this New York Style pizza.
Perhaps I'm being overly critical - technically, the store name is New York Style "Pizzeria." So maybe I shouldn't have expected New York style pizza.
Ironically the other pizza place very close by says nothing about it's pizza being New York style - but it's a lot closer than Venezias, and I highly recommend it.