Well "Philthy McNastys" is definitely an accurate description! Was there about a week ago for some beer to waste time. Going in was a mistake. Service staff were friendly, but slow and inattentive. The draught was actually warm (I did see it being poured) and the place was unkept. Have only been in one other time, and it wasn't great then, but it is truly not worth going now.
Can't judge food, since my party didn't order any, though I wouldn't test it. Plenty of alternatives in midtown.