I could be wrong, but I don't really get the impression that Arizona folks know or care about serious BBQ. That said, I've had good 'cue in other parts of the country, so I guess I should consider myself lucky that there's a place as good as Andrew's in my backyard. From the outside, I could smell the smoke, which I can't say that I've experienced at any other BBQ spot in the valley. One star just for that.
I've been here a few times and always get something different. They have daily specials all the time and are usually a good deal. Their menu is pretty extensive, the prices are reasonable, and I've never had a bad meal here. But this place is always DEAD. It's a shame - maybe people are more budget-conscious, or they aren't aware of this place (see first paragraph) - I just hope this place sticks around.