We had a gift certificate so we came here for our 7 year anniversary dinner. I was pleasantly surprised at the decor. The dining room was dimly lit and very intimate. It's a perfect place for a date night.
Prior to ordering, our server informed us the menu was changing tomorrow. Great... Guess we'll have what's on the old one. We started with the cheese curds. Wow! These might have been the best fried cheese curds I've ever had in my LIFE! Fresh light batter and creamy squeaky cheese curds. It came with a side of in house sauce. I wish I could say the same about the rest of the meal.
I had the "jumbo" scallops. Huge disappointment. The scallops were barely seared if at all. They were also sandy and not washed well. I've had jumbo scallops before and these guys must have been their little brothers. Only came with three... $26 for the plate.
My wife got the Mahi Mahi. This was also a disappointment. Lightly battered and served on top of butternut squash. It made it taste very sweet. The Brussels sprout side came shredded. Very strange and not tasty at all.
The seafood chowder was OK. I wasn't impressed with it either. The only other positive was we got a $10 of wine.
I'm giving it three stars mainly for the atmosphere and cheese curds. Hopefully the new menu is better. I might try it again.