Situated just a few stores down from New Zealand Cafe is one of my favorite fish stores. Family owned and operated, these guys know their stuff and are super nice.
Livestock is incredibly affordable and they always get a good variety. Organization isn't top notch, but they make due with the limited space. While the stock is limited, they do have many essential brands that most reefers will gravitate towards.
While I might window shop at other stores, Nemo's Reef is one of the few that I actually purchase from.