We decided to try My Pie tonight as my husband and I want to customize our pizzas due to dietary restrictions. My husband can't have dairy and I skip dairy in solidarity with him. So, we created a to-go order online. We were pleasantly surprised that they offered Daiya (dairy-free) cheese. Since my husband likes Daiya he got that and I decided to get no cheese (I didn't check any cheese option online, they didn't offer a "no-cheese" box to check).
I guess my husband should have checked the pizzas before he left the store because when he got home we saw that my pizza had mozzarella on it and his was missing his chicken.
The food itself was just ok. The toppings seemed just... flat, not much taste. Maybe it was just a Sunday night and things weren't as fresh?
Having them forget/mistake ingredients plus the taste being just bland was pretty upsetting considering the cost. I think next time we will try a different make your own pizza place.
Updated: after I left my review the owners almost immediately contacted me to apologize and make amends. I really appreciate them trying to fix their mistake & will think of going there again