I'm going to go back and I'll update the review. I thought it was a really nice place. The waitress was super awesome. But ny pizza with pepsi come on that should have been my first clue that this was not ny style. It was kind of doughy. The bottom was crisp so I'm confused at first. I couldn't fold my slice in half the way you are supposed to eat pizza. It was too think. I just didn't like the overall flavor. I will say I liked the sauce. I also liked the garlic knots. We ordered zucchini which I enjoyed but I just didn't love.
Walking around I saw some other really good looking options from the other tables. The only thing that didn't look good was the calzone that had olive oil and part on top. Again a sign of western pizza non-ny style.
The place is busy and I see a lot of good reviews. I was told about Sal's by a guy I know who is italian from NY who was raving about it. But please don't call this ny pizza that is an insult to east coasters who are always on the lookout for decint pizza.