Do NOT order a whole pizza pie here!!! You think you're getting a good deal, but you'll be sorry. We literally waited over 45 minutes for our pizza (they said it would take 15-20 minutes). After asking several more times and waiting for 20+ more minutes -- during which time they actually yelled at us, lied and claimed that the hold up was due to ordering a half vegetarian, half pepperoni pizza (totally not true considering they told us it was fine when we ordered it) -- we FINALLY received our pizza, and it was completely undercooked!! UNACCEPTABLE. I was so annoyed at this point that I took it back and asked them (as nicely as I could muster) to put it back in the oven. Several minutes of waiting (I'm sensing a pattern here, ha ha), we finally dug into our pie. The flavor was okay, but it was still undercooked. WTF!
Service at Sirrico's is beyond horrendous. We were not the only ones who were put through this ordeal. There were at least 2 other groups waiting for their pies, and everyone was seriously pissed off! I can't believe this place is still in business. Stay away at all costs! Or if you absolutely must have pizza at 3am while you're already in NY NY casino, only order by the slice!!!