Nestled in a row of sub-par and sometimes outright AWFUL tourist traps near the theatres, Kit Kat can always be counted on for simple quality. I often take visiting friends and family here since I know I can count on good, consistent food and excellent service.
I am a big fan of the pasta misto for 2 combo, especially any combo that involves the spicy sausage penne. I know that some people complain that the pasta is not homemade, but it's expertly prepared to be al dente and is topped off with with delicious sauces and mix-ins. I've never had a bad meal here.
The kitchen gets big points for their willingness to accommodate special requests. I regularly ask them to change up the sauces (i.e. red or rose sauce instead of cream) or substitute ingredients, and they always do so cheerfully. The servers are always friendly and fun, too.
On your way to your table, be sure to check out the tree that grows up through the restaurant and out through the roof! Many people pass it by without even noticing. It definitely adds some character to this King Street institution.
Finally, save room for dessert- they always have the dessert fridge fully-stocked with amazing Dufflet desserts. My favourite is the carrot cake with cream cheese icing. I'm incapable of resisting! Great coffee, too.