During college, I frequented the $1 slice places where the lines get more fun & interesting the later you go - I imagine Benny's to be the grown up, more sophisticated big brother of one of the college places.
Benny's sells pizza by the slice and by the pie - but don't think that you're going to eat your regular number of slices here. The pies are 28", which means a slice has to use two plates. Its a bit ridiculous. Its New York style pizza, thin crust with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. I've only tried the cheese and pepperoni, but they do have other toppings as well.
Benny's is a great NoDa addition, they have some awesome murals on the walls (and front of the store), and it will be a great stop if you're headed out to a brewery or two (or three!).