After watching Steve the butcher give a demo at Hometown Homegrown, I quickly became enamored of this place. It's since become my favorite place to buy meat. The cuts are fresher than I've gotten anywhere else, and what's more, I know that I'm a) putting money in the pocket of a local rancher, and b) avoiding loading up my body with mystery hormones. It might be a few bucks more, but the quality is absolutely worth it. The butchers will also happily help you choose the cut that meets your needs, and helpfully explain why.
As for the rest of the store -- I'll be honest, I go there for the meat and usually just pick up a few odds and ends that catch my eye. Often from their wide variety of artisanal chocolates!
Even if you only go for the butcher shop, though, it's worth the trip -- and the occasional street parking hassle.