I suppose I'd prefer to give it 3 1/2. It's a great place - the atmosphere is unique, and it's huge. The food is pretty good. I've never been blown away, but I've also never been totally disappointed either. Their pizzas are one of their best 'bar' dishes. Their perogies are pretty tasty too. I had their buffalo meatloaf once which was really good, but you need to ask for an extra side of sauce because it is a bit dry. During the October/November season, they have apple cider spiked with Captain Morgan which is possibly one of the best drinks I've ever had there. Their bread pudding is also very good, but very large.