Its all in the name here! The old fashioned is absolutely the best place in Madison to get... you guessed it; and Old Fashion. They have a drink menu dedicated to just Old Fashions from brandy, whisky, rum, etc. Whatever liquor you prefer in your drink they can do it. I particularly like there orange rum twist they have on the drink.
Fun here is also good, there cheese curds are awesome. Overall a good Madison Wisconsin staple.