I would give Toasted 5 Stars but I am a firm believer in the idea that there is always room for improvement. Just my policy. Found this place online and needed a new place to try on a Friday night. I was thinking "how hard can it be to make a decent grilled cheese sandwich" but these guys have turned it into an art form! You enter through the back of the dining room into a really roomy but somehow still cozy dining area. Overall a great vibe to the place. Casual and comfortable. We were greeted (from across the room) by a girl who rushed over to seat us. We ordered the Beer Battered French Fries as an appetizer... They were like crinkle cut twice baked potatoes. Super crisp on the outside and downright silky on the inside... very good. And very hot... you can tell they just got out of the fryer.
For the main course I went with the Turkey RaspBrie (clever name) with green apple. It's like Thanksgiving in a sandwich. The creamy brie and the salty havarti played quite nicely against the tart raspberry compote with just a little bite from the caramelized onion. The green apples added just enough crunch to make it more than a textural one-note dish. Super hearty Texas toast kept it all in place and I am proud to say I didn't need to use my fork! A well balanced, hearty, and overall excellent sandwich. I would be remiss if I failed to mention the house-made potato chips... crunchy, salty, and delicious. (They are available as an appetizer)
The wait staff were all very approachable... several stopped by to chat. My water glass was never empty.
Bottom line - great place - great service - great fries - and a great sandwich. I will definitely be adding Toasted to my go to list of restaurants!