I don't know if there is any Madison staple I will miss as much as Ian's when I move to Illinois. I have been countless times. I always get two slices - it is a hearty amount of food for $8. My absolute favorite is the Cheesy Potato with Ranch. It is addictive! I think my other favorite is called Smokey the Bandit (BBQ chicken and cheese). Obviously the Mac n' Cheese is a classic, but I usually don't choose it because I have so many other favorites with a bit more flavor. They always have a good one on special - most recently I tried a seafood alfredo slice. Although most people don't go for the salads, they have a surprisingly delicious build-your-own salad that tastes fresh. I always top it with the White Balsamic and Herb Vinaigrette. Finally, they sell Calliope's pints there, and who doesn't love Calliope's? I LOVE Ian's.