I walked in with a date after looking for good BBQ places in Toronto, thinking it was just like any other run of the mill BBQ place with good food. I asked for a table for 2, they said it'd be an hour wait, even for the bar and gave some pretty bad attitude as if I should know that. Immediately left after that. There was an open table too, and was an open table for 5 minutes even as we were deciding outside where to go next. The decor was fancy and didn't feel welcoming at all for a BBQ place.
BBQ is my favourite food, and when I go out I don't expect to be treated like some lower class citizen who didn't make reservations. It kills me because I'm sure the food is very good, but the attitude and atmosphere is definitely not for me.
Edit: I went back, meat was tasty, sat at the bar. Barkeep was extremely nice and agreed with not liking the reservation idea, got a free drink. Still not keen on it taking reservations, just silly and posh. Upgrading to 3/5 from 1/5.