I am only judging this place as a bar, never had the food. I'd rather give it 2.5 stars.
I came here with a colleague after a long, long travel experience to get to Pittsburgh.
They had a nice collection of beers including some local ones. The only negative side is that the bartender had almost no knowlege of what the beers were like so we had to just try our luck. The bartender had never tried any of the beers nor did he care about them. I would have liked to have more info in order to make smarter choices about which beers to get. At least one of them I would have avoided if I'd know more about it.
Perhaps he was just not used to encountering a beer geek.
I did pass by the place the next day around lunch and it was full of customers. For what ever that means.