Agree with others, food is decent and ambience makes the place. But that alone should not be the deciding factor for a 4-5. I had more than one experience with not so great smells from the kitchen (heavy bad fish smell) and emitting from the bathroom during my dinner. Really turned me off a couple times. But, this was during Restaurant week so maybe it factored into it. For the whole experience and only good food, I would say the most I can muster is a 3.