5 stars for the burgers...yum! The place is hidden in the new Union South on Dayton. Along with The Sett, comes other restaurants, including Bacock ice cream (another yum!)
But - I've only ever tried the burgers and fries, so I can't have say on the other menu items. But the burgers are definitely not frozen, you can tell they make them themselves. Atmosphere is great - quiet and cozy - cabin-type setting with big booths and a fire place. However, this is a bar, and haven't been in past lunchtime, so I imagine it can get quite loud - considering it's downtown in the University. Great price too for the quality of food you get - and it will fill you up.
I'll definitely be back!