Absolutely and unequivocally the best pizza in Cleveland. The crust shines here, crispy, salty, delicious. The toppings are of the highest quality it seems (but I think they changed which pepperoni they used). I always order a pepperoni and kalamata olive pizza and it's always great.
They seem to put a lot of care into what they do and I really appreciate that.
Their salads are huge and awesome too. Tasted the Greek salad and man they don't skimp on feta or kalamata olives at all.
I have not had their gnocchi. I hear it's amazing.
If they have the cheesecake in the cooler, buy it. It's fantastic.
* I am not going to review them on their slices. They just aren't as good as the whole pizza, but it doesn't knock them down at all for me. If you want a slice go to Vincenza's or NYC.