Never again. I bought 4 regular sized cupcakes from here on Thursday and today (Saturday) we still have two left. A big feat in our household but not really because these cupcakes suck.
The Red Velvet, the first one we tried, was grainy and chalky. The icing and the cake somehow resembled sand and left an unpleasant texture in our mouth. A few hours later we persevered and tried the Coconut one. While the cake was actually moist it was still a terrible cupcake. The icing to cupcake ratio is WAY off. I have never considered scraping off icing into the garbage until I tried these cupcakes. The coconut shreds on top were so dry and tasteless.
Update: Tried the other two: Blueberry and Cream and Peanutbutter Banana. I don't know what to tell you Prairie Girl but the colour blue doesn't equal the flavour blueberry. I've tried several crayons and the same holds true of orange, just for future reference. Peanutbutter Banana one was actually decent, but not worth $3.
And what about this place is meant to be anything about a Prairie or Girl? It looks like the store was designed by a corporate robot who moved to the city and couldn't comprehend interior decorating or touches of design.
None of the cupcakes in the sparse display had name tags. Instead you had to look and pick off a wall menu with pictures. Hello, have you ever been to a bakery? Did you think it was not enticing to see the actual cupcake next to it's name?
The icing on the cupcake was the man behind the counter didn't want to fill up my water bottle because he wasn't sure about the tap water. TORONTO TAP WATER. IN A BAKERY.
Wow, this place makes me so mad. I will never in my life recommend this place to anyone.