Stopped in recently after a fun night at Brush Bar and was very glad that we did! Pizza is delicious! The husband/wife team who own this place are pleasant and really from Italy. Wife is a little rough around the edges but I suspect it's from all the drunks who stop in there late in the evening and give her a hard time. We found her friendly and nice when we chatted about her Italian heritage. Sometimes you just have to make it about others and not about YOU. ;)
The restaurant itself is a little older and rough around the edges compared to other places in Old Town but in a way, it was refreshing to get something GENUINE instead of contrived like so many places there are. It's got a handful of tables and a high tops along the window but it's clearly meant more for take out than dine in.
The pizza was very yum. I had a slice of pepperoni and jalapeño which was excellent. My husband had a slice of Italian sausage and a slice of pepperoni. Both were great. The sausage wasn't too spicy and the cheese was excellent. We even got a pie to go to thank our babysitter (the big son) for a job well done. The pie to go was even tastier than the slices we had.
We will definitely go back to Best of Italy next time we have a pizza craving while visiting Scottsdale. It's worth the visit and I look forward to exploring more of the menu.