I've been to Carmen several times in the past few years, as I am a big fan of Torito in Kensington Market, which is owned by Carmen, as well.
I was lucky enough to have secured a reservation on a busy Saturday night to celebrate my daughter's 24th birthday.
Carmen herself was working busily on the floor, seating customers and creating a positive vibe in the space.
She made a recommendation on the vino, 6 Sombreros from the Rioja region. Was quite good - not very Rioja-like, but tasty none-the-less.
We went with tapas rather going the paella route.
Patatas Bravas
Alcachofas Fritas
Tortilla (while it's not on the menu, I usually ask for it to be brought over from the Mercat)
Padrones (unfortunately, none were hot, but still wonderfully tasty!)
Jicama con Aguacate
Ceviche Blanco
Gambas al Ajillo
Everything was very authentic, and in-line with my food experiences in Spain.
We also shared a nice almond torte for dessert.
Service was just right.
Not bothersome ... very helpful ... and knowledgeable.
I also enjoyed the conversation with our server, Cristian, who is from Mallorca, where I had spent a fair bit of time over many years.
Great place, great food, and amazing people.
It's the most authentic Spanish restaurant in Toronto.