Lost a star due to the setup. You walk in, get in line (sometimes out the door), order at a counter, then have to find free-for-all seating while your meal is prepared. Pretty annoying set up when it's crowded. Would have 5 stars if it was traditional restaurant service.
Menu could also be more descriptive. One of my party thought they were getting some kind of fries and we got something more like potato salad.
Aside from that, everything was fantastic. Got the lamb and it was cooked pretty rare (which they warn you about and which I was okay with) but it had a nice char and amazing flavor. Other people I was with both got the ribeye option, which was also fantastic, and had a fantastic char, providing the right amount of crisp.
A nice little touch was the side/dipping sauces they provide. There's a garlicy/softrito style sauce that's out of this world.