It gets a 5 based on the awesome pour of the black and tan!! (See pic) As a local, I love places like this in Cleveland and while there are times tourists or neophytes may populate this place there are some seriously dedicated locals who make this bar special. When other bar tenders come here to relax and have a beer to decompress that tells you all you need to know.
And as an example, when I ordered the black and tan the 7 other people drinking some sort of fruity shots had no idea what the bartender was pouring for me. I'm not trying to be snobby, I'm just pointing out that this place attracts a kind of eclectic crowd depending upon the day - which to me adds to the fun of this place.