I've been here twice - very conveniently located for me. It's an old school hardware store, a small space stuffed to the rafters with paintbrushes, wire, tools, etc.
The first time I was on an all-afternoon hunt for mason jars (I suppose they were out of season) to put my smoothies in - Target, Whole Foods, Giant Eagle, Joann, no one came through for me, but I found a dusty box of 12 - two options of sizes! - at Cedar Center Hardware.
The second time, I was looking for blue painters tape because my landlord was worried that the plastic I was planning to put up around the windows would peel off the paint (whereas I was worried I'd go broke paying for heat). The gentleman who ran the store was incredibly helpful and friendly and actually talked me OUT of buying the tape - it wouldn't have worked.
Friendly staff and everything you need, plus a mini parking lot in the back - what more could you ask for from a neighborhood hardware store?