I give it 4 stars for the unique PIE experience, but would give it a 3.5 if I could. Lots of savory and sweet options and cute diner vibe. I ordered the luscious lime pie ($7) which was fantastic. Loved that there was lots of whipped cream on top, and it was the right combo of tangy and sweet. Gingersnap crust and the lime zest on top made it just perfect. My friend, however, ordered the lemon meringue pie ($8) and it was quite a disappointment. The lemon curd was more of a cheesecake texture and the meringue was more like a goopy marshmallow than a pillowy meringue. My friend who is a self-professing "pie snob" was pretty bummed with it. Still tasted good and was definitely better than store-bought, but no comparison for me to a legit homemade lemon meringue pie from what I tasted. And I expected it to be darn good from a place that specializes in pies.
We went around 7 PM and it closes at 8 and was pretty quiet in there. Nice little spot and good server, so I would for sure go again for the lime pie or to try a different kind, but would definitely stay away from the lemon meringue as it just wasn't worth it.