Excellent custard, good shakes, good blizzards, etc. Seems locally owned, often staffed by high schoolers, only open in summer, it really reminds me of a place in my hometown. Very crowded most of the time.
Reason I can't give this 5 stars is that it is very expensive, even for the quality of the custard. But if you have the cash, it's definitely the go to place for custard in town, it's better than Culvers and way better than overpriced Coldstone and Marble Slab or whatever.