Okay, take the guy on the website with a grain of salt and you'll be fine. Yeah, he comes off as douchy and way over-the-top but I'm pretty sure it's all tongue-in-cheek and if you are "in on the joke" rather than put-off by it you're in for a good time along with your great meal.
I had the bone-in rib-eye and was very pleased with it. Some of the fellas at my table seamed to really enjoy their oyster appetizers.
Everything we had was very tasty and the atmosphere really is all it's sold as. You can pick out your own cut but the steaks were downstairs and my friends and I had been seated upstairs so we didn't bother. We just said "get us the big ones pal."
Go in, live the good life, and be sure and tell them Peter Rollins sent you.