I love the Village Tavern & over time it has become my go to place. Between my sister & me, we have probably eaten there some 200+ times, especially if you include take out. The service varies from good to excellent, but where they really shine is in their willingness to accommodate requests. They have managed every request we have ever thrown at them, & some of the people we have taken are really difficult (allergies, intolerances, etc.) Another thing I really like about the Village Tavern is the menu variety. I can get a burger & fries, or a Mexican salad (excellent, BTW), or Thai nachos (also excellent, but only order if you have a friend to share), or shrimp scampi. For someone who eats there all the time, variety is important.
The only thing I don't like about the Village Tavern is that in the Winter/Spring it seems to be full of snowbirds & it can be hard to get a table. (& they seem to crowd the lobby area with the intent of making sure that no one can get through.) So I make a reservation or get take out, no big deal, but something to note.