I don't quite understand the bad reviews. Yes the menu is slightly uninspired but it's always delicious! I've been here about 5 times and there is always great wine, salads, mains, etc.
Last visit I had the Rack of lamb. The lamb was perfect!! I think it was about $25 which is pricey but reasonable for Lamb...and with amazing mashed potatoes...though the greens it came with were way too salty.
The salads are great and other apps are excellent as well. The atmosphere is very, how shall I say, "old" rosedale. Lol but it's very comfy and cute. Servers are hit and miss. I've had some that are decent and knowledgable and others that were kinda odd. Owners/managements seems quite nice.
I'll definitely be back. They keep things pretty simple yet decadent and I dig it!