I'm reviewing this place for it's late night menu (10PM - close) and drinks, I've never come for dinner.
The late night menu is AWESOME. Best "drunk food" you will ever eat - and it's cheap for the quality that you get. I got a grass-fed beef burger with muenster cheese, amazing. My friend got a roast beef with horseradish - great! Everything tastes very quality and homemade. I think my burger was $8.95 - it was a steal! No sides or anything, but a very quality hunk of meat and flavor. Drinks aren't as cheap, I think a Jim Beam on the rocks was $6.50.
The atmosphere is great - it's like an old school steakhouse with a dark interior and half-moon booths. There is a bar you can sit at (and I think eat at) and then a back room. I've been there once in a dress and heels for drinks and once at midnight after an Against Me concert in jeans and sneakers and I didn't feel out of place either time - I probably wouldn't wear sneakers during dinner time though.
Try the late night menu! It's amazing!